Career Notes

How to evaluate a job offer — and negotiate it without the awkwardness

By Hannah Ephraim · 8 min read

Most people negotiate a job offer the way they'd return a wrong order at a restaurant — apologetically, quickly, and half-expecting to be told no. That's a shame, because negotiating an offer is one of the highest-value hours of work you'll ever do. A ten-minute conversation can be worth thousands of dollars a year, every year, because raises and bonuses usually build on your starting number.

Here's how to do it calmly, with the facts on your side.

Step 1: Work out what the market pays

Before you react to the number, find out whether it's a good number. No single source is perfect, so triangulate from a few:

  • Levels.fyi — the best source for tech and increasingly other fields; real, verified offers with base, bonus and equity broken out.
  • Glassdoor and LinkedIn Salary — broad coverage; treat the ranges as directional rather than exact.
  • Government data — in the US, the Bureau of Labor Statistics and state pay-transparency postings give you real, legal ranges. Many states now require salary ranges in job postings, so check the posting itself first.
  • People — a trusted recruiter or a friend in a similar role will tell you more in five minutes than an hour of browsing.

You're looking for a range, not a single magic number. If three sources cluster around $120k–$140k and your offer is $118k, you have a reasonable, factual case. If the offer is $135k, you know you're already near the top — which changes your strategy.

Step 2: Understand how salary bands actually work

Most mid-size and large companies don't pick salaries out of thin air. Roles are slotted into bands — a minimum, a midpoint and a maximum — usually tied to a level (e.g. 'Senior PM, Level 5'). A few things worth knowing:

  • The first offer is rarely the top of the band. Companies typically offer somewhere between the minimum and the midpoint, leaving room for negotiation and future raises.
  • The band matters more than the number. Ask what band and level the offer sits in. Being hired at the top of a lower band can mean a raise ceiling you hit immediately; being mid-band in a higher level leaves room to grow.
  • Base salary is the hardest to move; signing bonuses and equity are often easier. If the recruiter says base is capped, ask about a one-time signing bonus — it comes from a different budget.
  • Bands get reviewed, but slowly. If you accept at the bottom of the band, you may wait a year or more for a review cycle to catch you up.

Step 3: Look at the whole package, not just the base

Two offers with the same salary can be worth very different amounts. Before negotiating, total up: base, target bonus (and whether it actually pays out — ask what percentage of people got their full bonus last year), equity (and its vesting schedule), retirement matching, health premiums, vacation days, and flexibility. A $5k lower base with a real 15% bonus and fully paid health insurance often wins.

Also list what money can't buy: the manager, the learning curve, the commute, the mission. Negotiate the money with a spreadsheet; make the final decision with your whole life in view.

Step 4: Ask — calmly, specifically, and just once or twice

You don't need a dramatic performance. You need one clear, warm, specific ask. The formula: enthusiasm, then evidence, then the number.

Something like: 'I'm really excited about this — the team and the work are exactly what I want next. Looking at the market for this role in Boston, similar positions are landing in the $130–145k range. Given my experience running [specific relevant thing], would you be able to come up to $138k?'

Three rules:

  • Name a specific number, not a range. If you say '$130–140k,' you will get $130k.
  • Anchor slightly above your real target so there's room to meet in the middle.
  • Then stop talking. Silence feels terrible and works beautifully.

Step 5: Know your walk-away before you start

The single biggest factor in negotiation outcomes isn't charm — it's alternatives. Before the conversation, decide: what's the minimum package I'd genuinely accept? What would I do if they said no? If you have another offer, a current job you like, or savings that buy you time, say so (politely). If you don't, negotiate anyway — just anchor on the market evidence rather than ultimatums.

And a reassurance: companies almost never rescind an offer because someone negotiated professionally. The person on the other end has done this dozens of times. You're not being difficult; you're being normal.

The short version

  • Find the market range from three sources before reacting to the number.
  • Ask what band and level the offer sits in — it tells you how much room exists.
  • Compare total packages, not just base salary.
  • Make one specific, friendly ask, then be quiet.
  • Decide your walk-away number before the call, not during it.

Holding an offer right now? Yael Companion's Negotiation Tool gives you a market read, a personalized script and a ready-to-send counter-offer email. Free for Executive Members; one-time purchase for everyone else.

Try the Job Offer Negotiation Tool

← All Career Notes